Savory Whimsyfin Delight: Redridge fishing, the recipe and the orc costumes

You do not get to choose: the tooltip just reads "Eat me." and the game rolls pirate or ninja for you. Eaten raw, a Whimsyfin does something random, like a Deviate Fish: players have danced for two minutes, fallen asleep for 30 seconds, or been healed.

Orc outfitsChanged

October 1: the food now gives the orc versions of the pirate and ninja outfits. Until then men turned into a murloc and women into an ogre. Those two were stand-ins according to Blizzard, so expect something like them to return at some point.